At today’s default rates, a gas furnace costs less to heat with than a heat pump in every town listed. That holds even at COP 3.
In Edmonton, one GJ of heat costs about $5.52 from a gas furnace and about $18.89 from a heat pump at COP 3 (rates in force on ).
COP is the heat a heat pump delivers for each unit of electricity. It falls as the air gets colder, and the gap widens: at COP 2, one GJ costs about $28.33, and at COP 1.1 about $51.52.
What does a unit of heat cost in my town?
| Town | Gas furnace, 95 per cent | Heat pump, COP 3 | Heat pump, COP 2 | Heat pump, COP 1.1 | Electric resistance, COP 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Airdrie | about $5.85 | about $20.74 | about $31.11 | about $56.57 | about $62.22 |
| Beaumont | about $7.51 | about $20.56 | about $30.83 | about $56.06 | about $61.67 |
| Cochrane | about $5.38 | about $20.46 | about $30.69 | about $55.81 | about $61.39 |
| Edmonton | about $5.52 | about $18.89 | about $28.33 | about $51.52 | about $56.67 |
| Fort Saskatchewan | about $4.49 | about $19.26 | about $28.89 | about $52.53 | about $57.78 |
| Grande Prairie | about $5.41 | about $26.76 | about $40.14 | about $72.98 | about $80.28 |
| Leduc | about $7.61 | about $20.56 | about $30.83 | about $56.06 | about $61.67 |
| Sherwood Park | about $5.00 | about $19.26 | about $28.89 | about $52.53 | about $57.78 |
| Spruce Grove | about $5.42 | about $20.74 | about $31.11 | about $56.57 | about $62.22 |
| Stony Plain | about $5.43 | about $20.74 | about $31.11 | about $56.57 | about $62.22 |
Calgary is not in the table. Use your bill’s gas and electricity prices and usage charges to work out the cost there.
What these costs include
Worked out on the default gas and electricity rates and today’s delivery charges and town fees, with GST. Your plans’ prices will differ.
Tariffs in force on . These are usage charges only. Fixed daily charges are separate, because a home that keeps both connections pays them either way.
The charges behind these numbers
- C$1.458 per GJ (1 October 2026 to 31 October 2026) [source].
- C$0.330 per day (1 July 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$0.876 per day (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$1.000 per GJ (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$0.091 per GJ (1 May 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$1.357 per GJ (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$0.325 per GJ (1 September 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- 1.549% (1 November 2025 to 31 October 2026) [source].
- 35.00% (from 1 June 2026) [source].
- 2.50% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- 12.01¢ per kWh (1 January 2025 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$0.260 per day (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 0.1198¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- -0.59% (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$1.034442 per day (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 3.3477¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 0.0155¢ per kWh (1 October 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- 4.2560¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 20% (from 1 April 2021) [source].
- 1.04% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 1.0 Gigajoules (GJ) 277.7778 Kilowatt-hours (kW.h) (read 21 October 2026) [source].
- C$1.602 per GJ (1 October 2026 to 31 October 2026) [source].
- C$0.164 per day (from 1 August 2026) [source].
- C$2.028 per day (from 1 August 2026) [source].
- C$2.948 per GJ (from 1 August 2026) [source].
- C$0.869 per GJ (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$0.172 per GJ (1 May 2025 to 31 October 2026) [source].
- 28.50% (from 1 October 2025) [source].
- 0.4851% (from 1 April 2026) [source].
- 1.0617% (from 1 April 2026) [source].
- 17.25% (from 1 January 2020) [source].
- 1.29% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 20.00% (from 1 January 2016) [source].
- 2.00% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- 17% (from 1 January 2020) [source].
- 1.03% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- C$1.458 per GJ (1 October 2026 to 31 October 2026) [source].
- C$0.330 per day (1 July 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$0.997 per day (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$1.049 per GJ (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- C$0.091 per GJ (1 May 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$1.357 per GJ (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 1.549% (1 November 2025 to 31 October 2026) [source].
- 35.00% (from 16 January 2025) [source].
- 5.60% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- C$0.230 per day (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- C$0.72856 per day (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 1.783¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 0.130¢ per kWh (1 January 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- -0.016¢ per kWh (1 January 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- 0.103¢ per kWh (from 1 October 2026) [source].
- 4.050¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 1.388¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 0.00% (from 18 December 2024) [source].
- 3.40% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- 0% (from 1 October 2013) [source].
- 0.86% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 31.63% (from 1 March 2026) [source].
- 5.00% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- 12.02¢ per kWh (1 January 2025 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$0.558 per day (1 July 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$1.4125 per day (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 9.03¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 0.133¢ per kWh (1 January 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- -0.212¢ per kWh (1 January 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- 0.068¢ per kWh (1 October 2026 to 31 December 2026) [source].
- C$0.2698 per day (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 4.79¢ per kWh (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 12.26% (from 1 April 2026) [source].
- 31.00% (from 1 May 2026) [source].
- 0.4851% (from 1 April 2026) [source].
- 0.9458% (from 1 April 2026) [source].
- 18% (from 1 May 2026) [source].
- 1.03% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 22.00% (from 18 December 2024) [source].
- 0% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 0% (from 1 January 2026) [source].
- 0.85% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 35.00% (from 18 December 2024) [source].
- 2.30% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- 20% (from 1 January 2016) [source].
- 1.36% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
- 35.00% (from 18 December 2024) [source].
- 2.50% (from 1 February 2026) [source].
- 20% (from 1 January 2013) [source].
- 1.32% (from 1 July 2026) [source].
The furnace column uses an assumed efficiency. AFUE is the share of fuel energy delivered as heat over a season. The standard furnace regulation sets this minimum. Minimum AFUE is 95 percent for gas furnaces without integrated cooling, with input up to 225,000 BTU per hour and single-phase power, manufactured on or after July 3, 2019 (read 22 October 2026) [source]. Its exclusions include relocatable buildings and replacement non-condensing furnaces.
The energy conversion is 1.0 Gigajoules (GJ) 277.7778 Kilowatt-hours (kW.h) (read 21 October 2026) [source]. Divide gas cost by furnace efficiency. Divide electricity cost for the same energy by COP.
See the separate furnace burner and fan costs and cost of extra electricity use.
What is COP, and why does it matter in an Alberta winter?
COP means coefficient of performance. It is heat delivered divided by electricity used. A higher COP means less electricity for the same heat. A heat pump moves heat from outside, even when the air feels cold.
NRCan gives two air-source ranges. At 8°C, air-source heat pumps typically have COPs between 2.0 and 5.4 (read 30 October 2026) [source]. At -8°C, air-source COPs can range from 1.1 to 3.7 (read 30 October 2026) [source]. COP falls as the outdoor temperature drops.
For illustration
Suppose a made-up winter needs a steady 3 kW of heat. It has 600 mild hours at COP 3, 300 cold hours at COP 2 and 100 very cold hours at COP 1.1. That is 3,000 kWh of delivered heat. Electricity use is 600 + 450 + about 273, or about 1,323 kWh. The whole-winter COP is about 2.27. These hours and COPs illustrate the arithmetic; they are not a weather forecast or a model rating.
Do not apply a mild-weather COP to every winter hour. Seasonal ratings also need context: NRCan’s HSPF estimates use a climate similar to Ottawa (read 30 October 2026) [source].
Do heat pumps work in Alberta winters?
NRCan says Cold climate heat pumps can operate at temperatures as low as -30°C (read 30 October 2026) [source]. That describes cold climate equipment, rather than every heat pump. Check the model’s heat output and electricity use at your winter temperatures.
NRCan gives a range for other air-source equipment. Newer air-source models can have minimum operating temperatures between -15°C and -25°C (read 30 October 2026) [source]. Below the minimum operating temperature, supplemental heat must supply the home. Backup heat can be a gas furnace or electric resistance heat. Its running cost belongs in the winter total.
The lowest temperature a system works at is not the price-based switch point. The economic balance point is where supplemental heating becomes less costly than heat-pump operation (read 30 October 2026) [source]. Use your equipment’s instructions and your own plan prices when setting controls.
Is there a rebate today?
The Canada Greener Homes Grant: Closed. December 31, 2025, was the last day to submit your documents. (read 21 October 2026) [source]. The Canada Greener Homes Loan: Closed. Funding is fully committed. New loan applications cannot be approved. Homeowners with an approved loan still have funding available. (read 21 October 2026) [source].
For Alberta, the Oil to Heat Pump Affordability Program: Application intake is closed. July 31, 2026, was the last day to apply. Applicants had to heat their home with oil. Applications submitted before the deadline continue to be processed. (read 21 October 2026) [source].
The National Heat Pump Rebate is upcoming: Applications are due to open in early 2027. Eligible installations from November 1, 2026 can qualify retroactively once applications open. (read 30 October 2026) [source]. The announced amounts are conditional: Eligible households can receive $2,000, or up to $10,000 for low- to median-income households. (read 30 October 2026) [source]. Read the government’s current eligibility and application rules before counting on a payment.
See home energy rebates for other programme details.
What does this table leave out?
Purchase and installation prices are separate. So are financing costs, maintenance and your home’s heat loss. The table uses default rates rather than your plan’s price.
It prices heat delivered, rather than the hours a system runs. Furnace fan electricity is separate. Backup heat changes the total when it runs. A heat pump also cools the home, which adds value and electricity use outside the heating comparison.
For a monthly estimate, work out how much heat your home needs. Split that heat among the furnace, heat pump and backup system. Use the COP for each part of the winter, then add the fixed bill charges.
Does my plan change the answer?
Yes. Both the gas price per GJ and the electricity price per kWh move the comparison. Keep usage-based delivery, town fees and GST in each calculation. Use your own bill when your plan differs from the default rate.
Read fixed and floating plans before comparing energy prices.
A bill check, free during our launch
BillRobin is an Alberta service. We compare every plan we can confirm for your home, show them in order of estimated cost, and you decide. We never switch your plan, never phone you and never ask for banking details or a social insurance number.
Questions people ask
Is natural gas cheaper than electricity for heating in Alberta?
At today’s default rates, a gas furnace costs less to heat with than a heat pump in every town in the table, even at the highest COP shown. The colder the air, the lower a heat pump’s COP and the wider the gap. Your own plan’s gas and electricity prices can change this, so check them on your bill.
Do heat pumps work in Alberta winters?
Cold climate equipment can work in very cold weather, but every model has operating limits. Heat output and efficiency can fall as temperatures drop. Match the equipment to the home’s heat loss. Follow its backup heating requirements. A low operating temperature alone does not show that it can heat the whole house.
Can this table predict a monthly heating bill?
The table prices a unit of delivered heat. A monthly bill also depends on how much heat your home needs and how often each heat source runs. Weather, insulation and thermostat settings all matter. Apply the costs to your home’s heat demand and keep fixed account charges separate.
Does the running cost comparison include a heat pump rebate?
No. A rebate changes the purchase cost, while this table compares energy used for heat. Federal programmes have their own deadlines and eligibility rules. Read the programme terms before counting a rebate toward a purchase. Include installation costs, financing terms and cooling use when comparing the whole cost of the equipment.
Sources
Written by the BillRobin team. Updated .
Show the 45 sources
- Alberta Utilities Commission, Monthly natural gas rates (Current gas costs): Direct Energy Regulated Services - North and South; Apex Utilities Inc.
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Apex Utilities Inc., Appendix 1 - Rate Rider A, Franchise Tax Riders (Franchise Agreement and Rate Rider A County of Two Hills No. 21)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Apex Utilities Inc., Appendix 1 - Rate Rider B, District & Municipal Property Tax Riders (Rate Rider B 2025 Reconciliation and 2026/2027 Calculation)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Apex Utilities Inc., Appendix 2 - Rate schedules, Phase 2 Compliance Filing, Rates 1 and 11 effective August 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Apex Utilities Inc., Rate Rider G Third-Party Transportation Rate Rider, effective January 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Apex Utilities Inc., Rate Rider L Load Balancing Deferral Account Rider, effective May 1, 2025 to October 31, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Electric Ltd., Appendix 1 - Rider A municipal assessment, Rider A Municipal Assessment Surcharge, Table 1: Total Rider A (effective 2026 04 01)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Electric Ltd., Appendix 3 - 2026 interim price schedules, effective January 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Electric Ltd., Quarterly AESO DTS Deferral Account Rider S Application - Q4 2026, effective October 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Electric Ltd., Rider G Temporary Adjustment, effective January 1, 2026 to December 31, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., Appendix 1 - South Rate Rider B, Municipal Property Tax and Specific Costs (South Rate Rider B 2025 Reconciliation and 2026 Calculation), effective February 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., Appendix 2 - North Rider B, Municipal Property Tax and Specific Costs (North Rider A and North Rider B Rate Schedule Updates), effective July 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., Appendix 2 - Rate Rider A, South Rider "A" Municipal Franchise Fee (Franchise Agreement and Rate Rider A with the Town of Picture Butte), effective September 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., Appendix 2 – North Rider A, Municipal Franchise Fee, Town of Beaverlodge, effective November 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., Appendix 3 - Rider D, 2025 Unaccounted-For Gas Rider D and Rider P, Rider D effective November 1, 2025 (Decision 30255-D01-2025)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., ATCO Gas South Interim Rate Schedules, January 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., ATCO Gas South Transmission Service Charge (Rider T) Rate Schedule, January 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., South Rider "L" to all rates for crediting or debiting Load Balancing Deferral Account balances, effective May 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., South Rider "W" Weather Deferral Account Rider, effective September 1, 2026
- Alberta Utilities Commission: AUC Disposition 31030-D01-2026 (September 11, 2026), Appendix 1 - FortisAlberta Inc. 2026 Q4 QTAR filing, Rider Schedules (Quarterly Transmission Adjustment Rider)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: AUC Disposition 31032-D01-2026 (September 11, 2026), Appendix 1 - EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc. Rider K, Transmission Charge Deferral Account True-Up Rider (Short-Term Adjustment, effective October 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Direct Energy Regulated Services, 2026 Final Rate Schedules for DRT Service in ATCO Gas North Service Territory, effective July 1, 2026 (Appendix 4 - Direct Energy 2026 final North default rate tariff schedules, 2024-2026 Deferral Account Disposition)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Direct Energy Regulated Services, 2026 Final Rate Schedules for DRT Service in ATCO Gas South Service Territory, effective July 1, 2026 (Appendix 5 - Direct Energy 2026 final South default rate tariff schedules, 2024-2026 Deferral Account Disposition)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: Direct Energy Regulated Services, 2026 Final Rate Schedules for Electricity RRT Service, effective July 1, 2026 (Appendix 3 - Direct Energy 2026 final regulated rate tariff schedules, 2024-2026 Deferral Account Disposition)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc., 2026 Annual Performance-Based Regulation Rate Adjustment, Appendix 3 - 2026 Interim distribution access service rates (DT - Schedule 1, Distribution Access Service Tariff, effective January 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc., 2026 Annual Performance-Based Regulation Rate Adjustment, Appendix 4 - 2026 Interim system access service rates (DT - Schedule A, effective January 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc., Appendix 10 - Rider J, SAS True-Up Rider (Interim Adjustment, effective January 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc., Appendix 9 - 2026 Balancing Pool Rider G (Temporary Adjustment, effective January 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: EPCOR Energy Alberta GP Inc., Price Schedule Applicable to Regulated Rate Tariff Customers Outside the City of Edmonton (EEA Regulated Rate Tariff, FortisAlberta Inc.), effective July 1, 2026 (Appendix 5 - Fortis price schedule July 1, 2026, 2025-2027 Non-Energy Regulated Rate Tariff Compliance Filing)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: EPCOR Energy Alberta GP Inc., Price Schedule Applicable to Regulated Rate Tariff Customers within the City of Edmonton (EEA Regulated Rate Tariff, EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc.), effective July 1, 2026 (Appendix 3 - EDTI price schedule July 1, 2026, 2025-2027 Non-Energy Regulated Rate Tariff Compliance Filing)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: FortisAlberta Inc., 2026 Annual Performance-Based Regulation Rate Adjustment, Appendix 3 - 2026 interim rate schedule (Interim Rates, Options and Riders Schedules, January 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: FortisAlberta Inc., Appendix 1 - Municipal Assessment Rider A-1, 2026 Rate Sheets (Rider A-1 effective July 1, 2026)
- Alberta Utilities Commission: FortisAlberta Inc., Appendix 1 - Municipal franchise fee riders (Rates, Options and Riders Schedules, effective May 1, 2026)
- ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd., ATCO Gas North Rate Schedules, effective August 1, 2026
- Canada Energy Regulator: Energy conversion tables
- Environment and Climate Change Canada: National Heat Pump Rebate: upcoming programme
- EPCOR Distribution & Transmission Inc., Schedule - Franchise Fee Rates (Local Access Fee), effective January 1, 2026
- EPCOR, Rate of Last Resort (Edmonton)
- Natural Resources Canada: Canada Greener Homes Grant
- Natural Resources Canada: Canada Greener Homes Loan
- Natural Resources Canada: Find the facts about electric heat pumps
- Natural Resources Canada: Gas furnaces: energy efficiency regulations
- Natural Resources Canada: Heating and cooling with a heat pump
- Natural Resources Canada: Oil to Heat Pump Affordability Program
- www.directenergy.ca: Direct Energy Regulated Services, Residential Electricity Rates
https://billrobin.com/ca/en/alberta/energy/heat-pump-vs-gas-furnace?utm_medium=share&utm_source=page
Are you on the right energy plan?
Send your bills as PDFs. We compare the plans available at your address, and you decide. Free during our launch.
Check my bills, free- We never phone you
- We never switch your plan. You decide.